5 Teen Vogue Editors Try Out Canada Goose Coats For the Winter

Is it worth the hype?
5 Teen Vogue Editors Try Out Canada Goose Coats For the Winter

All products featured on Teen Vogue are independently selected by our editors. However, when you buy something through our retail links, we may earn an affiliate commission.

Welcome to ‘Teen Vogue Tries,’ a series where Teen Vogue editors try out some of the newest releases – from fashion to beauty – helping you go beyond the hype.

Canada Goose is all the rage. It's everywhere, and we needed to know what the hype was all about. On average, walking down the streets of New York City between December and March, you're bound to see a slew of Canada Goose jackets on the street. Living in the North East and in a city like NYC, that can snow all the way up until the ninth hour, it's vital to have a coat that can withstand all the elements. Because of this we decided to put Canada Goose to the test. A few of our editors tried out a recent collection from the Toronto-based brand.

The Live in the Open campaign celebrates three trailblazing women from the distinctly different worlds of cinematography, performance and sport. Interconnected by a relentless pursuit of purpose and the passion to be part of something bigger, actor, musician, writer and composer Sheila Atim, wildlife filmmaker and cinematographer Sophie Darlington and Olympic ice hockey goalie Kimberly Newell were the face of this collaboration. The collection includes the Copal Cashmere Crewneck and the Copal Cashmere Turtleneck. Designed with next-to-skin softness and breathability, the knitwear pieces are made with 100% Cashmere yarn. Crafted with Pima Cotton, an ultra-luxe water-repellent fabric with a matte, dry finish, the Garnet Puffer, Garnet Cropped Puffer and Garnet Vest feature a sleek interior lining, subtle elliptical hem and fixed down-filled hood or collar providing a modern, minimalistic silhouette which fits any outfit. Made with Lumina, a recycled fabric that is water-repellent and wind resistant with a super-soft sheen finish, the Rhoda Parka, Rhoda Jacket and Rhoda Vest offer premium warmth with a fixed wrap hood, off-centered snap button closers and an oversized quilted design. The collection includes the Copal Cashmere Crewneck and the Copal Cashmere Turtleneck. Designed with next-to-skin softness and breathability, the knitwear pieces are made with 100% Cashmere yarn. Below, read our review of the popular luxury outerwear brand so you can decide for yourself.

Claire Dodson, Senior Culture Editor

When it comes to coats, I’m admittedly about form over function. I fear what my colleague James Factora calls “excessive puff” — good in a s’more but not in a jacket. New York City winters be damned, I’m going to wear a stylish thin coat over layers, and if I freeze a little, at least I look cute. But the Junction Parka might have me changing my tune; while, yes, it’s not going to give you that broad-shouldered long-line Fran Leibowitz writer-in-the-dark effect, it provides something else: beautiful, cozy, non-sweaty warmth. Zipping up this coat and stepping out into the wind made me feel like I’d encased my torso in a heat bubble… I truly never realized coats could be warm without suffocating, puffy without being excessive. It’s a well-structured, well-insulated coat that I can wear for hours outside without being miserable, and the pale pink color is a nice aesthetic touch.

Junction Parka Black Label

Donya Momenian, Associate Fashion & Beauty Editor

I hate being cold, so I take my winter coats very seriously. Canada Goose’s new fit is definitely one of the most unique styles I’ve seen for a jacket. It’s nice because you can still show off your personal style while bundled up for the cold. I love the look and I feel like it can fit a lot of different aesthetics. Sometimes when things are cute I fear they won’t be practical, but this wasn’t the case for this. It fits great—a little extra room if you want to wear a thick sweater but the sleeves are cuffed so you won’t feel cold air coming in through there. My only drawback is that I wish it was a little longer. However, I think it can also be convenient that it’s shorter. The weight of the jacket isn’t too heavy either, so it’s easy to move in and carry around for those on the go. Most importantly, it’s super cozy and warm. Let’s just say, I totally understand the hype now.

Garnet Puffer

Juan Velasquez

People assume it never gets cold in Los Angeles, but you have to realize that 60 degrees in LA is basically 30 anywhere else. With that being said, the Garnet Puffer jacket is perfect for those chilly So Cal winter nights.This coat elevates my GORP aesthetic with a chic-tech vibe. I like to wear it unzipped and paired with Birkenstock sandals, camping socks and vintage Levis. I love the jacket’s luxurious coziness, it’s like walking around in a sleeping bag without looking like you simply forgot to get out of your snuggie before hitting the streets. You can really feel the quality of the fabric, since I wear it with a t -shirt underneath, the silky lining feels amazing on my arms. Most importantly for a puffer coat with some real insulation it is lightweight and leaves you feeling comfy and unencumbered.

Garnet Puffer

Kaitlyn McNab, Culture News Editor

If I had to rate my first Canada Goose coat, I’d give it a strong 9/10. The Rhoda Parka in Limestone is one of the most neutral colors I’ve ever owned in outerwear. It’s cool enough to pair with blacks or bluer tones, and warm enough to match browns and sunny tones. It also protects my 5’5" frame from vicious city winds by hitting the perfect below-knee length, having button closures and a dual zipper, and knit cuffs that preserve warmth in my arms. The only drawback is that, being a down jacket, the coat is quite large, fluffy, and light — which feels great to wear but can be a bit overwhelming to carry or store. This also means that one strong gust will knock the hood straight off of your head. With a little more weight and structure, this coat would be the coat of my absolute dreams.

Aiyana Ishmael, Associate Editor

As a Miami native I am always cold living in New York City. But, as a fashion lover, I never want to give up style. I have always heard good things about Canada Goose and was excited to see what the hype was all about. I often see these coats when I'm walking down the street and needed to know if it can withstand the cold. I will say i immediately loved the style and it's fit. It's hood was also deep and covered my entire head, which is always a concern for someone like me. I will say the coat was comfortable and kept me warm. I got the XXL in the style that I really wanted, mostly because I can fluctuate depending on the fit, but this one was a bit small so I definitely needed a 3X in their sizing. Overall I thought the coat was warm and will be something I use often over the next few months.

Marlow Jacket